Court Orders Immediate Withdrawal
During the hearing, the Court stated that the content appeared to undermine the dignity of the judiciary. It observed that such material could fall within the scope of criminal contempt if found to interfere with the administration of justice.
The bench directed the Centre and state authorities to comply with its order without delay. It also cautioned that any attempt to bypass the directive would invite serious consequences.
Show Cause Notices Issued
The Supreme Court has issued show cause notices to:
- The Secretary, Department of Education and Literacy (Ministry of Education)
- The Director of NCERT, Dr. Dinesh Prashad Saklani
They have been asked to explain why action should not be initiated under contempt or other relevant laws against those responsible for preparing the chapter.
The Court has also asked NCERT to submit:
- Names of members of the Teaching–Learning Materials Committee
- Qualifications and credentials of those involved in drafting and approving the chapter
Government’s Stand
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta informed the Court that the Government of India stands with the judiciary and will act in accordance with the Court’s directions. An unconditional apology was tendered on behalf of the Ministry of Education during the proceedings.
The matter has been listed for further hearing on March 11.
Background of the Case
The controversy relates to a section in a Class 8 Social Science textbook published by the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT). The chapter reportedly discussed issues related to corruption within the judiciary under a broader topic on the role of the judiciary in society.
Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal had earlier raised concerns before the bench, though the Court indicated it had already taken cognisance of the issue.
Important Details for Schools and Students
- Textbook affected: Class 8 NCERT Social Science
- Action ordered: Complete withdrawal and digital takedown
- Authorities involved: Supreme Court of India, Ministry of Education, NCERT
- Next hearing date: March 11
Schools are advised to verify whether the withdrawn edition is in circulation and follow official instructions issued by NCERT and the Ministry of Education.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Has the Supreme Court officially banned the textbook?
Yes, the Court has ordered an immediate ban and withdrawal of all copies.
2. Are students required to stop using the book immediately?
Schools are expected to follow official directions and discontinue use of the withdrawn edition.
3. Will a revised version be issued?
The Court has not announced any revision plan. Further clarity may emerge after the next hearing.
4. What should parents do?
Parents should consult their school authorities for updated guidance regarding study material.
What Students Should Do Next
Students should continue their studies using officially approved and updated materials provided by their schools. For accurate information, rely only on announcements from NCERT, the Ministry of Education, and the Supreme Court of India.
